I haven't read it, and probably won't bother. People told me that Thunder and Shadow was amazing too, but that was average at best in my opinion. But just reading the summary on the Wiki depressed me. Its good that they brought back Anyone Can Die to the modern clans, Warriors was beginning to be way too predictable without it. Still though, I am shocked that they killed off Billystorm. And Firefern?! Seriously!? She was the best one out of Leafstar and Billystorm's litter, and she's the one that dies?! Why didn't they axe off Harrybrook?
And is it just me, or is the -heart suffix being WAYY too overused? In this generation, we have Stormheart, Blossomheart, Lilyheart, Alderheart, Cinderheart and Brightheart are still around....
And Hawkwing has a romance with his first cousin? Can't say I am surprised, I think the Erin's having given up on trying to keep track of that stuff long ago. Still, modern SkyClan has a deep gene pool, being made up of rogues and kittypets and SkyClan descendants, and yet they STILL managed to accidentally pair up two cousins? Erin's, this is just pathetic.
It's sad that they conviently forgot about so many cats. Rockshade, Creekfeather and Shrewtooth were among my favourites.