The Ideal Starclan

[Barkfoot]

That's actually a really good interpretation of how a sort of "future vision" could work, I really like it! Make it consistent and that would definitely be a solid Starclan power. Void Events is also a nice way to limit power (and adds intrigue/plot possibilities, of course)

Adding another thing because I just thought of it- I don't like when it's implied that Starclan sends actual physical signs of things? Spoilers for Moth Flight's vision

(click to show/hide)

Like how there was this moth that led Moth Flight perfectly to where she needed to go? Steps the line into having too much power/control, I think?

That's the biggest example I can think of, but I'm sure there are other instances of this that I'm forgetting. It's not as common at least.

Did anyone else ever actually see the moth? I always chose to believe that the moth was a vision, not a real thing.

[Darkforestwarrior]

I seem to remember Micah seeing the moth too? Am I remembering incorrectly?

[Ravenflight123]

I think he does. But other than that, no one does except Moth Wing.

[Ravenheart]

Perfect Star Clan...

I think the reason there is the star clan is to keep the clans save from falling apart and live in an anarchy.

So in my opinion the Star Clans powers should be limited to give signs to the clans which give them hope in bad times so they have the power to recover from the tragedy.

On a scale from 1-10
Seeing in the future: 2
Physical strength; 4
Psychic strength to the clans: 10

[Lightning]

I seem to remember Micah seeing the moth too? Am I remembering incorrectly?

Aside from something from Micah, I'm pretty sure only Moth Flight could see said moth... I know towards the end of the book, in that little graphic novel thing, it does appear that only Moth Flight was able to see it...otherwise I think her kits might have said or done something when she just randomly left the den?

Yeah ^ but even with StarClan, the Clans still wind up in some pretty horrible situations... they only appear when they want to.